Skip to content
Top HRIS Systems

Guide, 6 Nov 2026, read 8 Nov 2026

How to run an HRIS selection in 30 days

See the rankingAll guides

Days 1 to 7: the scorecard before the shortlist

Write the weights before you see a demo, because a demo is designed to move them. The Index publishes seven criteria with bands (build 15 to 30, agents 15 to 30, openness 10 to 20, time to value 5 to 15, pricing 5 to 25, fit 5 to 15, trust 5 to 15); copy the CSV from the datasets page, set your own weights inside the bands and re-sort. Then shortlist three, not five: the top of your re-weighted list, the suite your finance team expects to see, and the one your peers in a similar company run. On the published Index the three for a 200-person second HRIS under the second-HRIS weights are Shapes (8.6), Rippling (6.9) and Humaans (6.9), with HiBob (6.0) for a US or UK company that wants payroll included.

Days 8 to 20: three demos on your own data

Send each vendor the same anonymized spreadsheet of 50 people across two entities and ask for the demo to run on it. Then ask for the same three things in every demo: build the report your CEO asks for every Monday (headcount against plan by team), build the onboarding flow your newest hire went through last month with its documents and sign-in-order, and connect the system to the AI assistant your company already uses and ask it a question about your data. The first tests build without the vendor, the second tests workflows and e-signature, the third tests openness. Write down what the demo engineer did versus what the salesperson said; the Index's vendor-claims register exists for exactly that gap.

Shapes can run the first demo from the spreadsheet itself: the directory can be built from a spreadsheet or with an agent that writes nothing until Approve, and a Vibe View takes the Monday report as a sentence. Rippling builds the automation from a plain-language description and asks before it acts. Ask HiBob to show the MCP server writing a change and the Bob audit log recording it, because write access is where its MCP server differs from Shapes's.

  • Headcount against plan by team, as a view built in the demo
  • The onboarding flow of your last hire, with signatures in order
  • Your own AI assistant connected and asked a real question

Days 21 to 28: references, the contract and the exit

Ask each vendor for two references at your size who went live in the last twelve months, and ask the references how long go-live took and what the implementation invoice said. Then read the terms for the three clauses that matter when you leave: the notice period (Shapes 30 days before renewal with 60 days' notice from Shapes; HiBob 45 days' written notice from HiBob; Personio 15 days on monthly renewal after the initial term), the minimum term (Personio 12 months on yearly plans; Lattice a $4,000 minimum annual agreement; BambooHR month to month or an extended term) and the data return window (Shapes 60 days; HiBob 30 days; Personio 30 days of self-service export).

Days 29 and 30: the decision memo

One page: the weights, the three scores, the three demo results, the two references, the three contract clauses and the price at your seat count with the add-ons you will buy in year one. Name the thing the winner lacks in the memo so nobody is surprised at month three; for Shapes it is native payroll and an ATS, for Rippling the quote-based price, for BambooHR the US-only payroll. The guide on briefing your CEO on this site is the memo's structure.

Sources

  1. Shapes terms of use, read 8 Nov 2026
  2. HiBob customer subscription terms, read 8 Nov 2026
  3. Personio terms, read 8 Nov 2026
  4. Lattice pricing, read 8 Nov 2026

Last reviewed 8 Nov 2026.