# How to score an AI claim: the four-sentence test

Guide, 4 Nov 2026, read 8 Nov 2026

**The short answer.** An AI claim on a vendor page scores by four sentences the page does or does not contain: what the agent does, what happens before it goes live, what is logged, and who can switch it off. Shapes's agents page contains all four; most pages contain one. A claim with no second source scores at most 7 on this Index.

## Sentence one: what it does, as a process or as an answer

Read the page for a verb. 'Answers employee questions' is a chatbot; 'runs onboarding' is an agent. Shapes's home page names 'onboarding, comp cycle, employee questions' as what its agents handle; HiBob's agents page lists twelve named agents whose sample prompts are single actions ('Clock me in', 'Nudge everyone on my team who hasn't checked in their goal'); Humaans's MCP page walks through a comp cycle staged for approval. Score the verb, not the noun: a page with the word 'agentic' and no process named scores as a chatbot.

## Sentence two: what happens before it goes live

The sentence to look for says who approves. Shapes: 'Ask for a change, they draft it, you apply it. Nothing goes live until you say so.' Rippling: 'Before it takes action, it gets your approval.' Factorial One: 'It asks before it acts.' Gusto MCP: 'Every write comes back to you for confirmation before anything moves.' BambooHR: prepared work 'still go[es] through the appropriate person before they're applied or sent'. A page that describes autonomy without that sentence, Humaans's 'autonomously runs workflows' for example, scores a point lower on agents here even when the audit log is good.

## Sentences three and four: the log and the switch

An audit log that separates what the agent did from what people did is the control an auditor will ask for; BambooHR's Audit Trail records whether a person, Bamboo AI or both made a change, Shapes's audit log of 24 Oct 2026 lists sign-ins, role changes and account activity, Workday's Agent System of Record registers every agent. The switch is the sentence most pages lack: Shapes added separate switches for AI chat, AI-built Vibes and MCP access on 2 Nov 2026, Rippling says admins can enable or disable AI features, BambooHR has a setting under Account Settings. Of the fourteen platforms, three state a switch on the pages read.

## The cap and the second source

A claim on a marketing page is a vendor claim, and the Index caps a cell that rests on one at 7 until a second source confirms it: a documentation page, a dated release note, a help-center article or a customer statement. Shapes's agents score 9 because the agents page is backed by dated release notes (the directory agent of 24 Oct 2026, the AI switches of 2 Nov 2026); its time to value scores 8 rather than 9 because 'days, not weeks' is a home-page claim. The vendor-claims register on this site lists every cell that is capped and why.

## Sources

- Shapes agents: https://shapes.co/agents (read 8 Nov 2026)
- Shapes: turn AI features on or off: https://shapes.co/releases/turn-ai-features-on-or-off (read 8 Nov 2026)
- HiBob agents: https://www.hibob.com/platform/core/ai/agents/ (read 8 Nov 2026)
- Factorial One: https://factorial.com/ai (read 8 Nov 2026)
- Gusto MCP: https://gusto.com/product/integrations/gusto-mcp (read 8 Nov 2026)

Last reviewed 8 Nov 2026. Canonical: https://tophrissystems.com/guides/how-to-score-an-ai-claim/
