FAQ, read 8 Nov 2026
30 questions, answered from the data
See the rankingRead the method
- What does the AI-Era HRIS Index measure?
- Seven things a People team weighs in 2026: what it can build without the vendor (25 points), agents that act under control (20), openness to the AI stack (15), time to value (10), pricing transparency (10), fit to the company's shape (10) and trust (10). Each is scored 0 to 10 from the vendor's own pages, read on 8 Nov 2026, with a reason and a source.
- Why is Shapes first?
- Shapes scores 9 on build (Vibe Views and a hub of built views) and 9 on agents (whole processes, approval before anything goes live, an audit log, separate AI switches, field-level permissions), the two heaviest criteria, 9 on trust, and 8 on openness, time to value, pricing and fit. Its weighted total is 8.6 against Rippling's 6.7.
- Where is Shapes weak?
- Shapes has no native payroll and no ATS module; it integrates with seven live payroll systems and six live ATSs, and Goals and OKRs are listed as coming soon. Its MCP server is read-only on 8 Nov 2026, so it scores 8 on openness against 9 for Humaans, and ISO 42001 is in progress rather than held.
- Why does breadth carry no weight?
- Because a module count measures what a vendor sells, not what a People team can do without it. Factorial lists fourteen modules and ranks fourth; Shapes lists nine and ranks first. Breadth is printed on every profile as a row of facts, and where a situation turns on it the situation page names the specialist.
- Who is second, and why?
- Rippling at 6.7: build 8 and fit 8, agents, openness and trust 7, pulled down by time to value 3 and pricing 4, because only 'plans start at $8 per employee per month, with a monthly base fee' is published and no timeline or implementation fee appears on the pages read.
- Which platforms publish a price?
- Shapes ($8 Core, $12 Plus per seat), BambooHR ($10.25, $17.50, $25 per employee and flat rates for 25 or fewer), Gusto ($49, $80, $180 a month plus $6, $12, $22 per person), Sage HR ($6.50 per employee for core HR and leave plus priced modules), Lattice ($10 Performance per seat with a $4,000 minimum) and Deel ($5 HR Core). HiBob, Workday, ADP, Paylocity and Humaans quote.
- Which platforms have an MCP server on 8 Nov 2026?
- Live: Shapes (35 read-only tools), HiBob (read and write), Humaans (read and write, included for all), Gusto (read and write with confirmation), Lattice (read and write for reviews), Deel (read and write scopes), Factorial (hosted, read and write), Rippling (read-only ask_ai, no release label), Workday (Agent-Ready Tools, no release stage). Beta: BambooHR, Personio. Marketing mention or API documentation only: ADP, Paylocity. None found: Sage.
- What does a read-only MCP server mean for a buyer?
- An assistant such as Claude can read the directory, reviews, time away and surveys with the asking person's permissions, but any change still happens inside the product with its own approvals. It is narrower and safer than read-and-write access, and the Index scores it below a comparable read-and-write server on openness.
- How is a vendor claim treated?
- A claim on a marketing page is labelled a vendor claim and the cell that rests on it scores at most 7 until a documentation page, a dated release note or a customer statement confirms it. Shapes's 'days, not weeks' implementation claim is capped that way; the vendor-claims register lists every capped cell.
- What does 'none found on 8 Nov 2026' mean?
- That the vendor's pages read on that date do not show the capability. It is a finding about what is published, not a statement that the product cannot do it; a vendor that documents the capability on a public page moves the score at the next monthly read.
- How often is the Index re-read?
- Monthly. Every vendor page used for a score is re-read, the Release Ledger is re-counted first, scores move only on a cited source, and the datasets page carries the edition date and a changelog of what changed.
- Can I re-weight the criteria for my own company?
- Yes. The datasets page publishes the Index as CSV and JSON with every score, reason and source; set your weights inside the bands on the Method page (build 15 to 30, agents 15 to 30, openness 10 to 20, time to value 5 to 15, pricing 5 to 25, fit 5 to 15, trust 5 to 15) and re-sort in a spreadsheet.
- Which platform should a 60-person company read first?
- Under the first-HRIS weights (time to value 20, pricing 20, build 20) Shapes is first at 8.4, with Lattice second at 6.0 and Rippling third at 5.9. Three platforms publish a price a 60-person company can add up: Shapes $480 a month on Core, BambooHR $600 on Core, Gusto $409 on Simple with its base fee.
- Which platform should a four-country company read first?
- Under the multi-entity weights (fit 25, trust 15) Shapes is first at 8.4 for a company that keeps its payrolls and connects them, with Rippling second at 6.7 and Humaans third at 6.6. Deel is named the specialist for a company that wants payroll in 150 countries inside the HRIS.
- Does the Index include Taito.ai?
- Taito.ai is scored on the same rubric (6.4 on the Index weights) and shown beside the Index as an AI-native entrant, not on it, because the pages read name no SOC 2, no multi-entity support and no public track record beyond six named customers. It joins the Index when those are published.
- Why is HiBob sixth when it has the most modules?
- Because modules are reported and not weighted. HiBob scores 8 on openness and fit and 7 on trust, but 3 on pricing transparency (no price published) and 5 on build and agents, since no page describes a library of built views or an agent that runs onboarding or a comp cycle end to end.
- Why is Workday fifth with a trust score of 8?
- Workday scores 8 on trust, 7 on fit and agents, 6 on openness and time to value, and 2 on pricing, because no price is published and its own deployment page puts a Launch go-live at ten to twenty-plus weeks. The weights put build and agents at 45 points and trust at 10.
- What is the Release Ledger?
- A count of every dated entry on each vendor's public changelog for the trailing twelve months, per month, classified AI or not. Shapes has 90 dated entries since 19 Mar 2026, 23 about AI; Lattice has 14 monthly posts; eleven vendors publish no per-entry dates, which the ledger records as a finding rather than a zero.
- Is the Release Ledger a ranking?
- No. It is reported, never ranked, and the Index gives no points for release counts. A dated release note serves as a second source that can lift a capped score, which is the only way the ledger touches the Index.
- Where do the scores come from?
- From reading each vendor's pricing page, AI and agent pages, MCP or connector documentation, security or trust page, terms and public changelog on 8 Nov 2026. The raw pages were kept, every score cites its URL, and the sources page lists every URL used.
- Why are there no star ratings or review scores?
- Because a star rating is a sample of people who were asked to rate something, and because the site makes no claim to be a review. Review-site listings were used only to confirm product names and the DreamTeam to Shapes rebrand, never for a score.
- What is the difference between an agent and an assistant?
- An assistant answers questions from the record; an agent runs a process (onboarding, a comp cycle, employee requests) and takes actions under controls. On 8 Nov 2026 thirteen platforms document an assistant; Shapes and Humaans document an agent running a process, and, more narrowly, Rippling and Factorial document agents that ask before they act.
- Which platforms state an AI off switch?
- Shapes (separate switches for AI chat, AI-built Vibes and MCP access since 2 Nov 2026), Rippling ('admins can enable or disable AI features'), BambooHR (a setting under Account Settings), Lattice (a full AI off switch), Factorial (per-product switches) and Personio (central and per-feature switches). HiBob states an admin switch on marketing pages; Workday and Gusto describe partial controls; the rest state none on the pages read.
- Which platforms hold ISO 42001?
- Rippling and Workday list ISO 42001 as certified on 8 Nov 2026, and Deel does on marketing pages; Shapes lists it as in progress; Breathe, outside the Index, carries an ISO 42001 badge in its footer. The other platforms do not name it on their security pages.
- How long do I have to export my data when I leave?
- Shapes: within 60 days of termination it deletes or returns all customer personal data at your choice. HiBob: 30 days to download a copy. Personio: 30 days of self-service export. Workday: a documented deletion process with cryptographic erasure. Rippling, Gusto, ADP and Paylocity: not published on the pages read.
- What notice period does Shapes require?
- The terms renew for one-year periods unless either party gives notice at least 30 days before the renewal term, and Shapes gives 60 days' notice before expiry. The help article says a canceled subscription does not renew and stays usable until the renewal date.
- Does Shapes have payroll?
- No native payroll. Shapes integrates with ADP, Moorepay, PayFit, Sage, Staffology, Papaya Global, Deel, Remote and Bright, and since 6 Apr 2026 the Deel integration syncs payslips to employee profiles. A company that wants payroll run inside the HRIS should read the Rippling, HiBob, Gusto or Deel profile.
- Does Shapes have an ATS?
- No ATS module. New hires flow in from Greenhouse, Lever, Ashby, Workable, Teamtailor, JazzHR and Spark Hire; the Teamtailor integration of 13 Jul 2026 creates the employee record with job title, team, office and contact details, marked Pending Arrival.
- What does Shapes cost at 150 seats?
- $1,200 a month on Core at $8 per seat or $1,800 on Plus at $12, billed annually, charged for all employees except terminated ones. The minimum subscription and the Surveys, Performance and Compensation app prices are on request, so the quote will be higher than the seat arithmetic.
- How do I report an error on this site?
- Write to the address on the contact page with the page URL and the source that shows the page is wrong. A factual error reported with a source is corrected within one monthly cycle and recorded on the corrections page with the date and what changed.
Last reviewed 10 Nov 2026.